3.5. Decommissioning

  1. The potential expenditure associated with decommissioning of Ossian and the share that could be secured in Scotland and the UK was not part of the SCDS process. It was assumed by the technical expert as part of the offshore wind economic model that there would be an expenditure of £150,000 per MW associated with decommissioning, based on the BVG Associates Guide to Floating Wind Farm (BVG Associates, 2023). This suggests that total spending would be £542 million.
  2. Additionally, it was assumed that 30% of this expenditure would be secured in Scotland and the UK and 70% elsewhere in the world (defined as “rWorld”), though there is potential for the Scottish and UK shares to be substantially higher, depending on development of the Scottish and UK economies over the next few decades (BVG Associates, 2021).

4. Economic Impact of PDE Option 1 (Commitment)

4.1. Construction

4.1.1. Ossian Impact

  1. Expenditure by socio-economic study area was estimated for Ossian based on the technical expert’s model of costs and the information provided in the SCDS. Therefore, it was assumed that under PDE Option 1, the total construction phase spend in Scotland could be £4.0 billion (37% of total expenditure) and total spend in the UK could be £5.1 billion (46% of total expenditure). The largest expenditure is associated with the manufacture of floating foundations, as shown in Table 4.1.

 

Table 4.1: PDE Option 1: Ossian Construction Spending by Category, Scotland and the UK

Parameters

Scotland

UK (Inc. Scotland)

Total (Scotland, rUK and rWorld)

Wind Turbine

 £885 m

 £1,331 m

 £3,785 m

Floating Foundation Manufacturing

 £1,916 m

 £1,916 m

 £2,335 m

Cables Supply

 £0 m

 £166 m

 £1,302 m

Offshore Cable Installation

 £187 m

 £262 m

 £1,249 m

Floating Foundations Installation

 £443 m

 £443 m

 £644 m

OSP

 £180 m

 £215 m

 £505 m

Development and Consenting Services

 £339 m

 £433 m

 £471 m

Floating Mooring Systems

 £86 m

 £171 m

 £429 m

Onshore Substation

 £0 m

 £129 m

 £280 m

Onshore Cable Installation

 £0 m

 £34 m

 £34 m

Operation and Maintenance Base

 £7 m

 £7 m

 £7 m

Total expenditure

 £4,043 m

 £5,108 m

 £11,042 m

Percentage of total expenditure (%)

37%

46%

100%

 

  1. Applying turnover per employee and turnover/GVA ratios for the relevant sectors, it was estimated that the direct economic impact of Ossian could be £1.6 billion and 23,880 years of employment in Scotland and £2.0 billion GVA and 29,670 years of employment in the UK (Table 4.2).

 

Table 4.2: PDE Option 1: Ossian Construction Direct Economic Impact, Scotland and the UK

Parameters

Scotland

UK

 

GVA

Years of Employment

GVA

Years of Employment

Wind Turbine

 £348 m

 5,170

 £523 m

 7,760

Floating Foundation Manufacturing

 £756 m

 10,900

 £756 m

 10,900

Cables Supply

 £0 m

 0 

 £61 m

 840

Offshore Cable Installation

 £48 m

 590

 £67 m

 820

Floating Foundations Installation

 £157 m

 2,440

 £157 m

 2,440

OSP

 £74 m

 1,290

 £86 m

 1,450

Development and Consenting Services

 £185 m

 2,890

 £236 m

 3,690

Floating Mooring Systems

 £38 m

 580

 £77 m

 1,160

Onshore Substation

 £0 m

 0

 £41 m

 470

Onshore Cable Installation

 £0 m

 0

 £11 m

 120

Operation and Maintenance Base

 £2 m

 30

 £2 m

 30

Total

 £1,609 m

 23,880

 £2,017 m

 29,670

 

  1. Applying GVA and employment multipliers it was therefore estimated that the total economic impact could be £2.7 billion GVA and 40,110 years of employment in Scotland, and £5.3 billion GVA and 75,170 years of employment in the UK (Table 4.3) (Table 4.4).

 

Table 4.3: PDE Option 1: Ossian Construction GVA impact, Scotland and the UK

Parameters

Scotland

UK

Direct GVA

 £1,609 m

 £2,017 m

Indirect GVA

 £611 m

 £1,646 m

Induced GVA

 £498 m

 £1,608 m

Total GVA

 £2,718 m

 £5,271 m

 

Table 4.4: PDE Option 1: Ossian Construction Employment impact, Scotland and the UK

Parameters

Scotland

UK

Direct Years of Employment

 23,880

 29,670

Indirect Years of Employment

 9,710

 22,610

Induced Years of Employment

 6,520

 22,890

Total Years of Employment

 40,110

 75,170

 

4.1.2. Array Impact

  1. For the Array it was estimated that the total spend could be £8.5 billion, of which £3.8 billion (44%) could be secured in Scotland and £4.5 billion (53%) could be secured in the UK (Table 4.5).

 

Table 4.5: PDE Option 1: Array Construction Spending by Category, Scotland and the UK

Parameters

Scotland

UK (Inc. Scotland)

Total (Scotland, rUK and rWorld)

Wind Turbine

 £885 m

 £1,331 m

 £3,785 m

Floating Foundation Manufacturing

 £1,916 m

 £1,916 m

 £2,335 m

Offshore Cable Installation

 £47 m

 £66 m

 £312 m

Cables Supply

 £0 m

 £106 m

 £212 m

OSP

 £180 m

 £215 m

 £505 m

Development and Consenting Services

 £214 m

 £273 m

 £297 m

Floating Mooring Systems

 £86 m

 £171 m

 £429 m

Floating Foundations Installation

 £443 m

 £443 m

 £644 m

Operation and Maintenance Base

 £7 m

 £7 m

 £7 m

Total

 £3,777 m

 £4,528 m

 £8,527 m

Percentage of total expenditure (%)

44%

53%

100%

 

  1. Applying turnover per employee and turnover/GVA ratios for the relevant sectors it was estimated that the direct economic impact of the Array could be £1.5 billion and 22,370 years of employment in Scotland and £1.8 billion GVA and 26,790 years of employment in the UK (Table 4.6).

 

Table 4.6: PDE Option 1: Array Construction Direct Economic Impact, Scotland and the UK

Parameters

Scotland

UK

 

GVA

Years of Employment

GVA

Years of Employment

Wind Turbine

 £348 m

 5,170

 £523 m

 7,760

Floating Foundation Manufacturing

 £756 m

 10,900

 £756 m

 10,900

Offshore Cable Installation

 £12 m

 150

 £17 m

 200

Cables Supply

 £0 m

 0

 £39 m

 520

OSP

 £74 m

 1,290

 £86 m

 1,450

Development and Consenting Services

 £116 m

 1,820

 £149 m

 2,320

Floating Mooring Systems

 £38 m

 580

 £77 m

 1,160

Floating Foundations Installation

 £157 m

 2,440

 £157 m

 2,440

Operation and Maintenance Base

 £2 m

 30

 £2 m

 30

Total

£1,505 m

22,370

£1,806 m

26,790

 

  1. Applying GVA and employment multipliers it was therefore estimated that the Array’s economic impact could be £2.5 billion GVA and 37,690 years of employment in Scotland, and £4.7 billion GVA and 67,500 years of employment in the UK (Table 4.7; Table 4.8).

 

Table 4.7: PDE Option 1: Array Construction Total GVA impact, Scotland and the UK

Parameters

Scotland

UK

Direct GVA

 £1,505 m

 £1,806 m

Indirect GVA

 £576 m

 £1,458 m

Induced GVA

 £468 m

 £1,440 m

Total GVA

 £2,549 m

 £4,704 m

 

Table 4.8: PDE Option 1: Array Construction Total Employment impact, Scotland and the UK

Parameters

Scotland

UK

Direct Years of Employment

 22,370

 26,790

Indirect Years of Employment

 9,180

 20,120

Induced Years of Employment

 6,140

 20,590

Total Years of Employment

 37,690

 67,500

 

  1. The spend at the primary construction port(s) is expected to be around £305 million, of which the largest contract is expected to be associated with marshalling harbour (£229 million). This would require a significant workforce, with an estimated peak direct employment of 480 jobs (Table 4.9).

 

Table 4.9: PDE Option 1: Array Construction Port Impact by Category

Parameters

Total Investment

Port Spend

Employment

Peak Employment

Wind Turbine Assembly

 £156 m

 £22 m

 110

 20

Marshalling Harbour

 £229 m

 £229 m

 1,860

 410

Offshore Logistics

 £13 m

 £13 m

 120

 30

Anchor Installation

 £201 m

 £40 m

 90

 20

Total

 £599 m

 £305 m

 2,180

 480